In terms of usefulness and success, Neutrogena Makeup Remover Wipes set the gold regular. These are typically not your average make-up wipes—they’re specifically formulated to remove as much as 99% of make-up, including water-resistant items like eyeliner, mascara, best makeup remover wipes sensitive skin and extended-use foundation. The Superior micellar-infused emollient method operates like a magnet, pulling out make-up and impurities without the need of tugging or rubbing.